The success of North by Northwest inspired a short-lived cycle of lighthearted romantic thrillers modeled on it (e.g. Charade; The Prize; Masquerade; Arabesque; A Man Could Get Killed; Blindfold; Bang! Bang! You’re Dead!). These films are unlike the popular James Bond thrillers and the many espionage capers inspired by the Bond phenomenon. Rather, the cycle, which is the basis of Cohan’s new book, features, not professional spies, but civilians: non-pros accidentally swept up in a conspiracy that undermines and destabilizes yet transforms their identities and at times challenges their sanity. Even more so than their equivocal innocence or guilt, what stands out are the heroes’ fragile identities and their shaky and unreliable perceptions of people and events. Domestic or foreign agents, or their sponsoring institutions, reveal themselves to be incompetent, indifferent, devious, manipulative, or corrupt, forcing the accidental hero to act on his own behalf. Here, the historical context is unmistakable, for after the botched attempt by the CIA to invade Cuba in 1961, its formerly authoritative and highly secretive image began to crack open domestically, fomenting doubt among Americans about the agency’s efficacy and ethics.
Skepticism about real spying, about the CIA as an authoritative and legitimate force, is thus always the implied backdrop of these thrillers, most notably when the CIA or a surrogate is absent, forcing the hero to act independently in order to expose a conspiracy and bring it to justice. In addition to this deep-seated suspicion of international espionage, two additional historical contexts triangulate the critical perspective Professor Cohan brings to these films: the attractive political virility of JFK and his New Frontiersmen (although most often problematized by the foreign female costars and their substantial roles in the plots) and the trope of theater and performing as the ground in which identities are formed and experienced (as popularized by Erving Goffman’s The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, published in a popular paperback in 1960). Finally, two variations of the basic template comprise this cycle, too, albeit as adjacent tracks: the heist film (e.g. Topkapi, Gambit, Dead Heat on a Merry-Go-Round, Grand Slam) and the paranoid thriller (e.g. The Manchurian Candidate, Mirage, The President’s Analyst, The Chairman), with each also featuring accidental heroes. The cycle’s three iterations, in effect, triangulate Cohan’s account of the accidental hero in a second way, with the amateur spy thrillers deriving from North by Northwest forming a base and the heist films and paranoid thrillers each providing a sideview.