Seminars
Studies in Modern Italy
Year Founded 1966
Seminar # 483
StatusActive
This seminar is concerned with political, social, cultural, and religious aspects of Italian life from 1815 to the present. In recent years, the seminar has stressed an interdisciplinary approach to Italian studies, increasing the participation of anthropologists and scholars of art, film, and literature. The seminar meets on the second Friday of the month, from September to May, to discuss a paper presented by a member or an invited speaker. Papers cover a wide range of topics, approaches, and methodologies. The seminar occasionally holds a day- long conference or a more restricted symposium to explore a topic in depth.
Chair/s
David Aliano
Rapporteur/s
Ricardo Andres Belisario
External Website
Meeting Schedule
Scheduled
Zoom
A Thematic Analysis of Political Storytelling in Italy
Speaker/s
Luciano Parisi, University of Exeter
Respondent/s
Jo Ann Cavallo, Columbia University
Abstract
I examine the writings of four Italian politicians, selected for the quality of their prose and the relevance of their institutional roles: Giorgia Meloni (the current Italian Prime Minister), Elly Schlein (the current opposition leader), Luca Zaia (governor of Veneto between 2010 and 2025) and Vincenzo De Luca (governor of Campania from 2015 to 2025, and now mayor of Salerno). What kind of stories do these politicians tell? What do they think about the role that widely shared stories play in a community? What do their stories have in common? While many scholars have studied the political orientations of Italian literary authors, far less attention has been given to texts written by politicians themselves. My research fills this gap. Raphaël Llorca, in Le roman national des marques (2023), claims that traditional storytellers (politicians and novelists) are no longer capable of telling communal stories. I disagree with him on this point: my first conclusion is that Italian politicians, in fact, fulfil their narrative function effectively. Their stories exemplify political visions and suggest types of behaviours to which listeners or readers can relate in precisely the ways Llorca describes. Some of the stories written by Meloni, Schlein, Zaia and De Luca emphasize individual commitment, ambition and efficiency, while others highlight collective effort, solidarity and honesty. Although they differ in focus, my second conclusion is that these divergent stories can be reconciled. This supports the "depolarization of our political system" that Carlo Guarnieri highlights in Il sistema politico Italiano (2021), countering simplified and overly negative portrayals of Italian politics.
Scheduled
The Italian Academy for Advanced Studies
Expanding Diasporic Identity: A Multi-Directional Path to the New “Italian” Writer
Speaker/s
Anthony Julian Tamburri, John D. Calandra Italian American Institute, Queens College/CUNY
Respondent/s
Fred Gardaphé, Queens College/CUNY
Abstract
This study examines the changing dynamics of the “Italian” writer and how we, as cultural critics, need to re-think our definitions of the new Italian writer. In so doing, we must also re-consider the notion of the geo-cultural zones that we characterize as “Italian.” Namely, how do we categorize that writer who, having left Italy and now living beyond its geo-cartographic boundaries, writes in Italian? Similarly, who is that other writer who, originating from another country that is both culturally and linguistically different from Italy, writes in Italian? Finally, where within these two groups do we position the writer of Italian origin who also lives in another country and, different from the previous two types of writers, composes his/her work in the language of his/her host country? This seemingly odd triad of writers does not consist of what some may call distinct and disparate categories. I would submit, instead, that they share a closer relationship than some might imagine. First, they are all dialoguing to some degree or another with the sign we know as ‘Italy’. Second, at least two of the groups are “de-riva-tive” of Italy whereas the third, in its own right, is “ar-riva-tive”; the first two leaving, the third arriving, yet the common denominator is still Italy. It remains the central point of commonality.
Scheduled
Zoom
Building at Life’s Limit: High-altitude Science and the Making of Modern Italy
Speaker/s
An Tairan, ETH Zurich
Respondent/s
Angelo Caglioti, Barnard College
Abstract
What does it mean to produce knowledge at the limits of human endurance? Inaugurated in 1893 on the border between Italy and Switzerland, the Queen Margherita Hut atop Monte Rosa remains to this day the highest building in Europe. This paper argues that it was not merely a site where science happened to meet nationalism, but a place where both projects depended on the same underlying logic: that extreme environments singularly reveal, test, and ultimately forge the capacities of bodies, institutions, and nations alike. Drawing on the writings of the Torinese physiologist Angelo Mosso alongside the archives of the Italian Alpine Club and the Sella family, I trace how a specific convergence of post-Risorgimento nation-building and late nineteenth-century experimental science produced a research program that could only have existed in this particular historical context. Mosso’s physiological investigations into human limits at altitude and the Alpine Club’s nationalist ambitions in the high Alps were not merely parallel projects that happened to share a building—they were, for a brief and fragile period, the same project, made possible by an extreme environment that rendered both scientists and alpinists equally vulnerable and mutually interdependent. The paper then follows the gradual unraveling of this convergence, as the shared institutional and physical space that hostile conditions had made necessary became, in more settled circumstances, the very terrain of bitter conflict and exclusion. In recovering this history, I propose that the Margherita Hut offers an unexpected lens onto the relationship between Italian scientific culture and national imagination in the liberal era—one in which the alpine frontier, at once natural, political, and physiological, was never merely a backdrop to modern Italy's self-making, but its very condition of possibility.
Scheduled
The Italian Academy for Advanced Studies
Italy’s First Female Cartoonist: Laughter and Violence between Rear-guard and Avant-garde
Speaker/s
Jennifer Griffiths, Max Planck Institute in Rome
Respondent/s
Ara Merjian, New York University
Abstract
Adriana Bisi Fabbri (1881-1918) exhibited with the Futurists and historians of art have often labeled her a member of this group, but, like many women, her position within the avant-garde was marginal and ambivalent. Her cousin, Umberto Boccioni, invited her to exhibit at the first Futurist group show in 1911, but didn’t appreciate the caricatures of bourgeois womanhood that she submitted. She found an admirer in fellow satirist Luciano Folgore, who warned her that Futurist founder, F.T. Marinetti, was too elitist to do much in support of her humorous art. In 1915, she joined the staff of Il Popolo d’Italia, making her Italy’s first professional female political cartoonist. Yet she signed her cartoons with the gender-neutral Adrì and often attended editorial meetings dressed as a man. She was aware of her status as an “exceptional woman” in a man’s world. “Intelligence has no sex,” she told a colleague. A blurring of “high” and “low” art and an interest in the comedic, have come to be identified as harbingers of modernism, but the role women played as active makers of popular culture is underexplored. The outbreak of World War I tested political loyalties: Mussolini broke with the socialist party over his irredentist desires to enter the war on the side of the Allies. He founded Il Popolo d’Italia as a pro-war propaganda tool and Adrì became a cog in its machine; between 1915 and 1917, feminist sentiments took a backseat to patriotism as she created numerous images dramatizing German, Austro-Hungarian, and Ottoman aggressions. This talk will explore her political cartoons as part of a rearguard effort to promote Italian intervention, situating them in relation to early- twentieth-century discourses about the innately aggressive and tragic character of humor (Freud, Bergson, Pirandello). It will argue that Adrì offers us a window onto the complex development of Italian feminist consciousness at the start of the twentieth century, before this process was interrupted by the forces of war and authoritarianism.
Scheduled
The Italian Academy for Advanced Studies
From Red Spain to Fascist Prison: The Counter Memoir of Italo Orciani 1937-1941
Speaker/s
Marla Stone, Occidental College and Brian Griffith, California State University, Fresno
Respondent/s
Roy Domenico, University of Scranton
Abstract
This paper analyzes the ‘counter memoir’ of Italo Orciani, an Italian grifter who, once rejected by the Italian Fascist militia fighting in Spain, joined the International Brigades. After several months in the Garibaldi Brigade, Orciani left Spain only to be arrested in September 1937 and sent to political confinement on the island of Tremiti. Once there, Orciani composed a ‘memoir’/ confession/ propaganda screed, designed to impress the Fascist authorities of his conversion to the Fascist cause because of the atrocities and immorality that he saw in “Red Spain.” This paper, addresses Orciani’s experiences in civil war-era Spain as told through the ideologically shifting prism of his campaign to liberate himself from political confinement in Southern Italy. Through Orciani’s counter memoir, the complexities, manipulations, and reactivity of Fascist political confinement emerge in the ways in which Orciani mobilized Fascist antisemitic and anti-communist discourses to make his case for conversion and confession to the Fascist authorities. In search of clemency, Orciani produced a counter memoir which transforms his personal experience fighting in the Garibaldi brigade in 1937 into a set piece of Fascist propaganda, revealing the ideological priorities of the Fascist regime in the late 1930s as it elevated Nazi-influenced antisemitic and transnational anticommunist tropes about the global communist-Jewish conspiracy which, they argued, was launched in Spain for the purpose of Soviet Union global domination. The Orciani memoir stands out as the only text about the International Brigades written from the perspective of non-leftist within the militias of Republican Spain.
Scheduled
The Italian Academy for Advanced Studies
A New Humanism? Subjectivity, the Body, and the Absolute in Contemporary Literary Representations of Female Sainthood
Speaker/s
Francesca Parmeggiani, Fordham University
Respondent/s
Jane Tylus, Yale University
Abstract
In “Speaking of God: The Post-Secular Challenge for Italian Feminist Thought and Practices” (AdI 2011), I argued for a constructive dialogue between diverse feminist experiences in Italy, both secular and religious, to address shared concerns for agency and social justice. In my current research, I continue exploring women’s relationship with politics and religion in modern Italy by examining 21st-century literary depictions of secular feminism vis-à-vis monastic life. More specifically, I delve into readers’ “curiosity” about monastic life and the radical choice of service and prayer that this life entails and consider Dacia Maraini’s In Praise of Disobedience: Clare of Assisi (2013) and Julia Kristeva’s Teresa, My Love. An Imagined Life of the Saint of Avila (2008). By reading these novels (partly hagiographies, partly autobiographies) comparatively, I discuss the language that contemporary culture employs to relate the encounter of the female subject with the absolute while investigating the notion of agency it advocates for women. Relevant to this study are other intellectual and artistic experiences. Feminist scholars have studied monastic life and women’s mysticism to interrogate the past and articulate new forms of expression of women’s bodies and minds. Feminist theology has redefined the ways in which we read and understand Scripture and access religion and its institutions. Cinema is the artistic medium which, in recent years, has offered the most original interrogations of faith, sainthood and the meaning of religious experience in today’s world. In my research, I weave these different voices together – each critically challenged by and constructively engaging with the other and the Christian tradition – to discuss how, by looking at the past and being challenged by it, contemporary literature and thinking by women configure new forms of participation and new models of spiritual practices in our post-secular society.
Scheduled
The Italian Academy for Advanced Studies
Not So Beautiful: Lucia Mondella and the Limits of the Novel
Speaker/s
Giulia Ricca, Hamilton School, University of Florida
Respondent/s
Morena Corradi, Queens College, CUNY
Abstract
Why does Manzoni spend some of the final pages of I promessi sposi insisting that Lucia is not beautiful? When Renzo and Lucia settle in a new village after their marriage, the locals are disappointed to discover that the famous Lucia does not look like a princess. The scene is unsettling, and strangely disproportionate: at the very moment when the novel is rushing toward its conclusion, Manzoni pauses to dwell on the scandal of Lucia’s unimpressive appearance. My chapter argues that the episode is not incidental, but central to Manzoni’s aesthetics and to his skepticism—declared in Del romanzo storico—toward the novel itself. Lucia’s beauty is remarkably indeterminate. Unlike the heroines of the eighteenth-century English novel or the Gothic romance, she is never fully described, never framed within a recognizable literary canon of feminine beauty. Through readings of Fielding’s Sophia Western, Apuleius’ Psyche, Gothic heroines such as Gertrude, and Manzoni’s own reflections on aesthetics, I argue that Lucia’s “insipidity” is not a deficiency but a deliberate anti-romanesque principle. Manzoni strips Lucia of the exceptional, spectacular, and emotionally excessive beauty expected of novelistic heroines in order to imagine another form of beauty altogether. That alternative emerges most clearly in the plague chapters, especially in the figure of Cecilia’s mother, whose “Lombard beauty” reveals a spiritual beauty that resists both sensual idealization and aesthetic codification. My chapter ultimately proposes that I promessi sposi transforms the problem of feminine beauty into a meditation on literary beauty itself. Lucia’s elusive appearance becomes the sign of a deeper tension within the novel: Manzoni’s desire for a form of truth and beauty that the conventions of fiction can approach only imperfectly. In this sense, Lucia’s famous insipidity marks not the failure of the novel, but the limit against which Manzoni pushes the genre.
Showing all 7 results
Past Meetings
Scheduled
The Italian Academy for Advanced Studies
A Tribute to Marta Petrusewicz and Reflections on the Sixtieth Anniversary of the Columbia University Seminar in Modern Italian Studies
Abstract
This special meeting pays tribute to the scholarship of a long-standing member and former seminar chair: Marta Petrusewicz, an internationally renowned historian and a mentor and dear friend to many of us in the Seminar and commemorates the sixtieth anniversary of the seminar in Modern Italian Studies. The first panel includes leading scholars in the field of modern Italian studies who will offer their assessment of Marta Petrusewicz's pathbreaking work and its influence, followed by a second panel of former and current seminar chairs, rapporteurs, and longstanding members who will reflect on the past, present, and future of seminar, including how the seminar and wider field of modern Italian studies has changed over the years as well as promising directions in the field. Refreshments will be served.
Scheduled
The Italian Academy for Advanced Studies
At Roman Bricktop’s: The Holy Hustler of Hollywood on the Tiber
Speaker/s
Melanie Masterton, California Institute of Technology
Respondent/s
Jessica Harris, Saint John’s University
Abstract
African American performer and club owner Ada “Bricktop” Smith’s fourteen years in Rome, from late 1950 until 1964, and her visits to Italy thereafter, have all but escaped critical notice, as scholarship has coalesced entirely around her remarkable career in interwar Paris. My talk will contextualize, drawing on print culture and her eponymous memoir, Bricktop’s presence as a cultural icon in Rome as a club owner, performer, tastemaker, and philanthropist. I consider her club on the Via Veneto as a space for desegregationist, antifascist relationalities, frequented as it was in this period of “Hollywood on the Tiber” by international artists, musicians, and celebrities of the Italian cinema, such as Bricktop’s close friend, Anna Magnani, and by cultural ambassadors and politicians. What I term Bricktop’s “radical hospitality” courses through her subversive stage performances and her philanthropy in Rome alike, which garnered her a nickname she relished, the “Holy Hustler.” Newly converted to Catholicism, Bricktop drew proceeds from her nightclub to fight poverty in Southern Italy and to aid orphans and single mothers. Bricktop’s radical hospitality sits in the tension between her philanthropic activism and her fostering an elegant, exclusive club in Rome for the rich and powerful. It is this latter audience to whom she addressed her signature, nightly performances of the Cole Porter song “Miss Otis Regrets,” whose estranging lyrics narrate a white society woman’s lynching by a mob. In the protest tradition of the anti-lynching song, Bricktop resists from Rome racialized violence and antiblackness at home through her embodied, reiterative performance of “Miss Otis Regrets.” Her ritualized performances and simultaneous call to fight Italian poverty, are in provocative tension with her reputation for curating a scene of joyous sociality for her guests. Bricktop’s celebrated presence in Rome opens new pathways for complicating postwar Italian attitudes toward race and nation. This proposed talk comes from the third chapter of my manuscript in progress, Black Mediterranean Forms: African American Cultural Workers in Cold War Rome, which situates post-World War II Rome as a hub of cutting-edge African American literature, performance, and visual culture and collaboration with Italian creative circles.
Showing all 2 results
For older seminar meetings, please reference your seminar’s page in the Annual Report.